POLICY LE14 (CP12)
Alterations to Listed Buildings

Applications for alterations or extensions to listed buildings must have regard to the scale, proportions, character and detailing of the existing building (both internally and externally)and of its windows and doorways. Any proposals which adversely affect have an unacceptable impact on the listed building will not be permitted. Applications will be assessed against the following criteria:

1. the importance of the building, its intrinsic architectural and historic interest and rarity, and its significance to the local distinctiveness and character of the district;
2. the particular physical features of the building
3. the setting of the building and its contribution to the local scene;
4. the extent to which the proposed works would bring substantial benefits for the community.

6.59 Carlisle District has a rich variety of historic buildings of all periods from the mediaeval Guildhall to the striking Victorian Parks and Terraces laid out by the Devonshire Estate. These along with many rural churches and farmsteads contribute greatly to the architectural and historic significance of the area and define the character of the local built heritage. Carlisle District has approximately 1600 buildings of special architectural or historic interest, including a great wealth of local red sandstone buildings. Within the City Centre, the Castle, Courts, Old Town Hall, Guildhall, Cathedral, Tithe Barn and Old Tullie House are all Grade 1 listed. The diversity of listed buildings in the rural area ranges from tower houses and peles such as the Grade 1 Listed Naworth Castle, and several characteristic examples of north Cumbrian vernacular architecture ranging from fine sandstone farmhouses to clay walled and cruck framed cottages and farm buildings.

6.60 This mixture of historic buildings gives special character to the towns, villages and countryside. However, these buildings need to be carefully and responsibly preserved. Proposals to alter, extend or demolish a listed building therefore require listed building consent. As the responsible Authority for listed building control, the City Council will expect any alterations or repairs to external elevations to respect the existing materials and match them in texture, quality and colour. Any renewal of doors and windows should be in keeping with the age and character of the building.

6.61 Certain works to listed buildings will also require planning permission. However, the issuing of planning permission will not automatically result in the issuing of listedbuilding consent. Listed building consent will be required even when there is no requirement for planning permission, for example when altering or replacing windows or doors, rendering or painting outside walls, replacing natural materials with an alternative, installing solar panels or satellite antennae, fixing advertisement signs or sunshades, and altering or removing interior features of interest.